Reynolda House: The Estate, the Family, and the Stories Left Behind
Winston-Salem, North Carolina
There are places that seem to hold more than just the history written down in books.
Places where the buildings, the grounds, and the stories of the people who once called them home all seem to linger long after the years have passed.
Just outside the heart of Winston-Salem, North Carolina, sits one of those places: Reynolda House.
Today, visitors know Reynolda as a historic estate, an art museum, a collection of gardens, and a beautifully preserved piece of North Carolina history. But behind the carefully maintained grounds and impressive architecture is a story that reaches back more than a century. It is a story of a wealthy tobacco family, a woman's ambitious vision, a working farm, a community of employees and their families, and a series of personal tragedies that left their mark on the property.
And, if local stories are to be believed, there may be a little more to Reynolda than what can be found in its history books.
Before There Was Reynolda House
To understand the estate, we have to go back to the late nineteenth century.
Richard Joshua Reynolds, better known as R.J. Reynolds, arrived in Winston, North Carolina, in 1874. The community would eventually become part of Winston-Salem, but at the time it was a growing Piedmont town with opportunities for business and industry.
In 1875, Reynolds established his own plug tobacco factory. Over the following decades, his business grew into one of the most influential tobacco companies in the country. Products such as Prince Albert pipe tobacco and Camel cigarettes helped make the Reynolds name nationally recognized.
With that success came considerable wealth.
In 1905, R.J. Reynolds married Katharine Smith, a woman who would become just as important to the story of Reynolda as her husband. Katharine was twenty-five years old, while R.J. was fifty-five. The two were first cousins once removed and had known one another for years.
Katharine had a vision that went beyond building a grand country home. She wanted a place where her family could enjoy a healthier lifestyle, where agriculture could be improved, and where the surrounding land could become a productive, self-sustaining
community.
In 1906, she began purchasing land outside Winston. Over the next thirteen years, she made twenty-seven separate land acquisitions that eventually formed the Reynolda estate.
Building a Country Estate
The Reynolda property eventually covered approximately 1,067 acres.
Katharine worked with Philadelphia architect Charles Barton Keen and landscape architect Thomas W. Sears to bring her plans to life.
The main residence was designed in the style of an American country bungalow, blending Arts and Crafts influences with Colonial Revival details. It was constructed using reinforced concrete, a modern building material for the period.
The house featured broad porches, heavy columns, a low sweeping roof, and carefully planned interior spaces. Although it was an enormous residence, Katharine referred to it as the bungalow.
The home contained approximately sixty rooms, including eight bedrooms. Its total historic area, including later additions, eventually reached more than 33,000 square feet.
Construction and development took place over several years, with the family finally moving into the completed home in December 1917.
But the house was only one part of the operation.
Reynolda was designed as an entire working estate, with barns, cottages, a dairy, greenhouses, gardens, a school, a post office, recreational facilities, and its own village.
There was even a power and heating plant to help serve the property.
It was practically a small town of its own.
A Farm Built for the Future
Katharine Reynolds was interested in more than appearances. She wanted Reynolda to demonstrate modern agricultural methods and show that a diversified farm could be productive and profitable.
The estate included hundreds of acres devoted to farming, livestock, dairy production, grain, and vegetables.
Farmers from the surrounding area were invited to visit and learn about the agricultural methods being used at Reynolda.
The property included dairy barns, livestock facilities, a blacksmith shop, greenhouses, and extensive gardens.
A large greenhouse operation supplied plants and flowers, while the formal gardens were designed to be both beautiful and useful.
The landscape included a man-made lake known as Lake Katharine, created with a stone-faced dam. The lake covered approximately sixteen acres and provided opportunities for fishing, canoeing, and recreation.
There were also tennis courts, swimming facilities, stables, and a golf course.
A polo field added another recreational attraction.
The estate was intended to provide a comfortable and productive environment for the
Reynolds family while serving as an example of what modern country living and progressive agriculture could look like.
The People Who Made Reynolda Work
It is easy to look at an estate like Reynolda and focus on the wealthy family who owned it.
But a property of this size did not run itself.
Farm supervisors, dairy workers, gardeners, mechanics, domestic employees, laborers, and their families all played a part in keeping the estate operating.
Reynolda was home to a working community, and not everyone who lived there experienced the property in the same way.
One particularly important part of its history is the African American community known as Five Row.
Five Row was a segregated residential community established for Black farmworkers and their families who worked on the Reynolda estate. It was located along Silas Creek, away from the main house and the primary village buildings.
The community began developing during the 1910s and included two rows of cottages, a boarding house, and a building that served as both a school and a church.
The Five Row School provided academic instruction and also hosted Sunday worship services.
Families raised children there, maintained gardens, kept livestock and poultry, and formed close relationships with their neighbors.
Although some workers earned better wages than they could find elsewhere, the living conditions were not equal to those enjoyed by residents of the main village. Five Row homes did not have indoor running water or electricity. Families relied on kerosene lamps, coal heaters, and shared water sources.
One resident, Flora Pledger, remembered Five Row fondly as a close-knit community where neighbors looked after one another.
Her memories remind us that history is not only about the people whose names appear on the grand estate's records. It is also about the families who built their lives there.
Five Row existed into the late 1950s. The community was eventually demolished around 1960–1961 to make way for Silas Creek Parkway.
Some residents salvaged materials from their former homes to help build new houses, and Flora Pledger successfully petitioned for the relocation of the community's church building.
Today, the story of Five Row is an important part of Reynolda's historical record.
The First Great Loss at Reynolda
The Reynolds family moved into the house in December 1917.
By that time, R.J. Reynolds was seriously ill with what is now believed to have been pancreatic cancer.
He died on July 29, 1918.
His funeral was the first public event held at Reynolda House.
Katharine was left to raise four young children while managing the estate, its farm operations, and the many responsibilities that came with the property.
Rather than allowing the estate to fade into the background, she continued expanding her vision.
She supported education, agricultural development, and community projects. She also donated land for a new high school named in honor of her first husband, R.J. Reynolds High School.
In 1921, Katharine married J. Edward Johnston, who had served as principal of the Reynolda School.
Their marriage brought another chapter to the estate's story.
But it would not last long.
In May 1924, Katharine gave birth to a son, J. Edward Johnston Jr. Her health suffered following the delivery, and she died from a blood clot only days later.
She was forty-four years old.
The woman who had envisioned, planned, and overseen the creation of Reynolda was gone.
The estate was placed in trust while her children grew older.
Another Generation, Another Chapter
In 1934, Katharine and R.J.'s daughter Mary Reynolds Babcock and her husband, Charles H. Babcock Sr., acquired Reynolda from the other family heirs.
Mary and Charlie continued maintaining the estate, making changes to the home while attempting to preserve its original character.
The house was updated to suit their family and the guests they entertained.
Among the additions were an indoor swimming pool, recreation spaces, a game room, and a guest house connected to the main residence.
The property continued to evolve, but its earlier history was never far away.
And then came another tragedy.

The Death of Zachary Smith Reynolds
One of the most unsettling chapters in Reynolda's history occurred in July 1932.
Zachary Smith Reynolds, the youngest son of R.J. and Katharine Reynolds, died from a gunshot wound inside the family home.
Known as Smith, he was fascinated by aviation and had become one of the youngest licensed pilots in the country.
He was twenty years old.
The circumstances surrounding his death became a major mystery.
Smith had been at a gathering at Reynolda, and the events leading up to the shooting involved a complicated personal situation, family relationships, and conflicting accounts.
The central question was whether his death was a suicide, an accident, or murder.
Investigators examined the circumstances. A grand jury considered the case, and newspapers followed the story closely.
Despite the attention, the mystery was never conclusively resolved.
For decades, the subject was not something the museum regularly discussed with visitors.
That eventually changed.
In 2023, Reynolda presented an exhibition titled Smith & Libby: Two Rings, Seven Months, One Bullet, examining the case through historical records, newspaper accounts, photographs, and artifacts.
The exhibition offered visitors an opportunity to examine the evidence and the history surrounding the young man's death.
It is important to distinguish this documented tragedy from the paranormal stories associated with the property. There is no verified evidence connecting Smith's death to any reported supernatural activity.
Still, it remains one of the most talked-about chapters in the history of the house.
From Family Home to Museum
After the Babcock family years, Reynolda began another transformation.
In 1964, Charles Babcock established Reynolda House, Inc., as a nonprofit organization dedicated to arts and education.
The house opened to the public as the Reynolda House Museum of American Art in 1967.
The museum initially displayed a small collection of American paintings. Over the years, that collection grew considerably.
Today, visitors can explore American art spanning several centuries, along with historic furnishings, decorative arts, family objects, and preserved rooms that help tell the story of the Reynolds family.
The estate also became part of a larger partnership with Wake Forest University.
A portion of the original land had been donated to the university by the Babcock family, and the surrounding property gradually developed into the community visitors recognize today.
The Reynolda Historic District was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980.
The old farm village buildings were adapted for new purposes, becoming shops, restaurants, offices, and gathering spaces.
What was once a self-contained country estate is now a place where history, education, art, and everyday community life meet.
The Lady in White
Now, this is where the story takes a turn toward the unexplained.
According to a local ghost story featured by Visit Winston-Salem, Reynolda has its own reported apparition: a mysterious woman in white.
The figure is said to appear in the gardens, sometimes surrounded by mist. Some accounts describe her as moving on horseback.
Reported sightings have been associated with the area around the old boathouse and Lake Katharine, which has since partially filled with sediment and become a wetlands habitat.
The figure is commonly identified in the legend as Katharine Smith Reynolds.
It is an interesting association considering how much of Reynolda's original design and development came from her personal vision.
She selected the land, planned the estate, oversaw its construction, and continued managing it after R.J. Reynolds died.
Her life was closely tied to the property.
But we need to be clear about what is known and what is reported.
The historical record establishes Katharine's connection to Reynolda and documents her death in 1924. The woman-in-white story is a local paranormal legend, not a verified historical event.
We have not established the identities of the original witnesses, the dates of the reported sightings, or independent documentation confirming the accounts.
That does not mean the story should be dismissed. It means it deserves further research before anyone presents it as fact.
What Remains Today?
Reynolda is no longer the isolated country estate it once was, but many pieces of its original landscape and architecture remain.
Visitors can explore the historic house museum, gardens, conservatory, walking paths, and Reynolda Village.
The museum is located at:
Reynolda House Museum of American Art
2250 Reynolda Road
Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106
The gardens and grounds are open during daylight hours throughout the year, and admission to the gardens and grounds is free. The museum has separate operating hours and admission arrangements.
Reynolda Village, located nearby, includes shops, restaurants, and historic buildings that once supported the original estate.
The old buildings have been repurposed, but their original uses remain part of the property's story.
For anyone interested in history, architecture, gardens, or the unexplained, Reynolda offers plenty to explore.
A Place Where History Still Has a Voice
When we look at Reynolda House, we see more than a beautiful old residence.
We see the vision of Katharine Reynolds, the business empire built by R.J. Reynolds, and the lives of the people who worked the land and maintained the estate.
We see the history of Five Row, a community that deserves to be remembered alongside the grand house.
We see family losses, unanswered questions, and a young man's mysterious death that continues to draw historical interest.
And then there are the stories of the woman in white, the mist near the old lake, and the possibility that some visitors have experienced something they cannot quite explain.
At Dark Hollar, we believe history deserves to come first.
Before we call a place haunted, we want to understand who lived there, what happened there, and what has actually been documented.
Because sometimes the history is haunting enough on its own.
And sometimes, even after the history has been written down, there are still questions left hanging in the air.
UPDATE:
A Medic's Memories: An Unsettling Feeling Inside Reynolda
Sometimes a place leaves an impression on you long before you ever consider investigating the paranormal.
For one member of the Dark Hollar team, Reynolda House is one of those places.
Years before becoming involved in paranormal research, she visited the estate several times while working as a medic, responding to patients there.
She remembers the main building as enormous, with an atmosphere that was difficult to describe. Each time she entered, she experienced an unsettling feeling, almost as though someone was watching her.
There were also strange moments when she would hear voices but see no one nearby.
She remembers the house having an echo, and she is quick to acknowledge that the sounds could have traveled from another room or another part of the building. At the time, she wasn't thinking about ghosts or investigating anything unexplained. She was there to do her job.
Still, the feeling stayed with her.
Looking back now, with years of paranormal research behind her, she remembers those visits differently. Not as proof of a haunting, but as experiences that made an impression she never quite forgot.
Sometimes the most interesting stories come from people who weren't looking for anything unusual in the first place.
That medic is ME!
Research • Document • Preserve • Investigate.
Dark Hollar — Southern Appalachian Paranormal
Places They Linger



Comments